Amy,
Out here, here's what sells:
- Brioche
- Chocolate croissants/rolls
- One or two-serving tarts and pies
- Challah
- Cookies
- Artisan breads
Of course, Telluride is not San Francisco -- quite -- so you'll want to tweak that for local tastes. Having "mini" pies and tarts is really helpful, though, in any area where you have a lot of single people and childless couples.